Some words about laughter

“It is the heart that is not yet sure of its God that is afraid to laugh in His presence.”

Have you ever wondered what Beethoven wrote at the end of his life? Well, contrary to what one might possibly think, instead of chasing after solemn affairs, Beethoven sought refuge in the endless power of laughter.

“The simplest truth about man is that he is a very strange being, almost in the sense of being a stranger on the earth. […] Alone among the animals, he is shaken with the beautiful madness called laughter; as if he had caught sight of some secret in the very shape of the universe hidden from the universe itself.”

Beethoven did not know what he was letting himself in for. Anton Diabelli, a composer and prominent music publisher, sent a copy of a theme he wrote to 50 different composers and he requested them to write a variation after the theme for a composition set that he would later use to promote his publishing firm. Beethoven, being one of the recipients of the theme, refused to participate in the project since he thought the theme was, according to his words, “cobbler’s patch” or “trash.”  

But Beethoven must have been able to see something no one else was able to see. He ended up writing up to seven variations of the so-called “trash” theme and set these aside for some years (a time he used to compose the Missa Solemnis and his three last piano sonatas, among other pieces). He resumed his work and ended up writing 33 variations that he now he gives the title of “transformations.” But these “transformations” are so audacious and visionary, so boring and sublime, sometimes I feel tempted to use the word “transmutations.”

Beethoven dissected the features of the theme that best served his purpose and put down on paper his whole philosophy about life. Brendel said that each of these transformations “confirmed, adorned and glorified. . . [but rather] improved, parodied, ridiculed, disclaimed, transfigured, mourned, stamped out, and finally uplifted.” Diabelli’s limited talent seemed to be the perfect raw material for Beethoven’s limitless talents to flourish. And here, my friends, we are witnessing one of the most beautiful examples in composition in music history. Even Alfred Brendel considers this piece as “the greatest of all piano works.”

Beethoven did not need wings to fly. He was given a stone and he made wings out of it. Isn’t that one of our main goals in life? Isn’t it so important not what we are being given but what we make out of it? That might give us a hint of what freedom is all about, when no longer we are dependent on things external but internal. Jorge Luis Borges said something along these lines: “A writer – but in general, all beings – need to thinkthat whatever happens to him can be then turned into a tool for expression. All things are given with a purpose, but an artist must feel this even more strongly. Everything that happens to us, our humiliations, our miseries, even our feelings of shame, everything, can be considered as raw material, like clay, so our art can take any form.”

When we arrive at the variation number XX (the one Liszt liked to call the “Sphinx”) we are at the presence of one of the most iconic, enigmatic and surreal passages in all music history. Some reminiscences of the theme, mostly its melodic contour, can still be hinted. I find it a true wonder in music. Sometimes, when I am at the presence of an unexpected plot turn, a subtle smile appears in my lips, and I find myself staring in awe and asking myself, how is it possible that a mere human has been able to do this. As what happens with Cervantes, Melville, Quevedo, Borges… humour permeates all their work. That might be just be a confirmation we are standing in the presence of a work of genius. And anyways, our God is full of humour too. But that’s for another time.

What is humor but a thread so thin between one world and another, wherein truth usually lies, where opposites almost touch? Isn’t it there, in the thinnest of threads, where the opportunity to glimpse “the universe hidden from universe itself” really lies?

Jean Paul (a contemporary writer of Beethoven, and often compared to him) understood humor as the “inverted sublime […] [which] lowers the sublime, while raising up the trivial, and […] sets the trivial beside the sublime and so annihilates both, since in relation to the infinite everything is the same and nothing.” In the Emerald Tablet we can read the following: “It is truest and most certain of all things. That which is above is as that which is below, and that which is below is as that which is above, to accomplish the one thing of all most wonderful…” We can also find this in Proverbs: “Even in laughter the heart is sorrowful…” (14:13).

And if you think about it, where was Jesus born? It would have been more credible to present him into this world in fancier setting. Instead, he was born in the lowest place of earth, a cave. Not an altar nor a throne – contemporaneously, a star, the highest that the human eye can reach, was watching the whole spectacle from above. This is something G. K. Chesterton in his book The Everlasting Man says, “the highest cannot stand without the lowest.”

After the first hearing of the variations, listeners are usually basically mad. These variations may sound banal or even utterly boring on a simple hearing. And I am the first one who felt this way. I even said to my piano teacher, when he suggested me playing the piece, “isn’t it, too virtuosic?” I always heard many derogatory comments about this piece but I never gave myself the opportunity to study it and come to a conclusion of my own. But we can only reap a reward proportionate to our efforts – and I found the harvest to be never-ending. Whenever you go back to a work of art and it feels like it is a living thing, like it is coming to life every time you return to it, then you are probably be staring at a masterpiece.

Maybe the highest cannot live without the lowest after all. Maybe that is why only who loses his soul might find it. Maybe that is why, “nowhere are we so tempted but at the very steps of the altar.” CSL, Screwtape Letters.

Ishmael, Moby Dick’s protagonist, also stumbles upon this truth: “There are certain queer times and occasions in this strange mixed affair we call life when a man takes this whole universe for a vast practical joke, though the wit thereof he but dimly discerns, and more than suspects that the joke is at nobody’s expense but his own. […] That odd sort of wayward mood I am speaking of, comes over a man only in some time of extreme tribulation; it comes in the very midst of his earnestness, so that what just before might have seemed to him a thing most momentous, now seems but a part of the general joke. There is nothing like the perils of whaling to breed this free and easy sort of genial, desperado philosophy; and with it I now regarded this whole voyage of the Pequod, and the great White Whale its object.”

A desperado moment might as well be an invitation to actually put into practice what we so far only knew as theory, for true spirituality being enacted.

“It might reasonably be maintained that the true object of all human life is play. Earth is a task garden; heaven is a playground. To be at last in such secure innocence that one can juggle with the universe and the stars, to be so good that one can treat everything as a joke – that may be, perhaps, the real end and final holiday of human souls.”

It is amazing, sometimes, what you can do with what you find in the trash.

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *